Suicidology Among First Responders: A Literature Review of Causal and Protective Factors

March 5, 2024

By: Cory H. Cannady, BCBA, LBA, DBH Candidate at Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Heath Studies, written for the course DBH 9016 – Suicidology and Phenomenology

Prevalence of Suicide Among First Responders

Suicide is the 10th leading cause of death for Americans of any age claiming the lives of 47,000 people in 2017 (Vigil et al., 2020). Suicidal ideation, suicide attempts, and completed suicide, however, are at a significantly and disproportionately higher rate among first responders including law enforcement officers, firefighters, and emergency medical personnel (Aldrich & Cerel, 2022; Ringer et al., 2021; Stanley et al., 2019; Streeb et al., 2019). Among these, firefighters are at the highest risk for suicide compared to the other professions (Streeb et al., 2019). This may be attributed to many different factors that will be discussed later.

According to Aldrich and Cerel (2019) a little over 25% of firefighters considered suicide, and around 12% made a suicide plan. Streeb et al. (2019) reported even higher rates of suicidal ideation (46.8%), suicide plans (29.2%), and suicide attempts (15.5%) among firefighters. This is at a higher rate than the general population which is around 5.6-14.3%, 3.9%, and 1.9-8.7% respectively (Streeb et al., 2019). Though there is more research on the suicidal behavior of firefighters these numbers are also higher for other first responders including law enforcement officers and emergency medical personnel. According to Vigil et al. (2022) 298 firefighter suicides and 84 emergency medical personnel suicides were recorded between 1999-2017. There is no doubt a need for investigation into causal and preventative factors of suicide in first responders.

Causal Factors

Many factors associated with the jobs of first responders may contribute to the rate of suicide among this population. Among these arise a few theories that may account for, to an extent, a predisposition or genetic factor related to suicidal ideation and completion. Outside of these theories regular causal pathways include ongoing work-related stress, post-traumatic stress disorder, high rates of anxiety and depression, sleep disturbances, and alcohol use (Aldrich & Cerel, 2022; Vigil et al., 2019)

Eusociality and Suicide

Ringer et al. (2021) discuss a eusociality-based account for suicidal behavior among first responders. This theory introduces that eusociality is where every member of a society has a specific role to play within the society. Those of first responders fall into the public defender positions within society, and thereby have a need to defend the society in whatever capacity they can such as putting out fires, aiding those with medical emergencies, or defending against threats to the society. Many of these positions also take an oath of office requiring their ongoing defense of society.

Within this theory, there may be a genetic factor associated with enrolling in this type of service which includes certain similar characteristics across individuals. These include a self-sacrificial understanding that may be a part of their job, a heightened tolerance for pain, regular want to exercise, and the want and/or need to serve others (Ringer et al., 2021). These characteristics, though maybe genetic, may cause one’s interest in beginning a career as a first responder.

Also within this framework there are explanations for suicidal behavior. Perceived burdensomeness, guilt, and self-disgust may contribute to suicidal behavior (Ringer et al., 2021). All of these reasons for suicidal behavior are a direct result of the actual chosen career.

Perceived burdensomeness may come from being unable to contribute to the team at an equal level as others due to many reasons such as mental or physical health problems, poor decision making on a scene, or unable to connect with other team members. Guilt and self-disgust most often are associated with outcomes from a scene that were uncontrollable but one feels responsible for.

Suicide within this framework occurs when one’s societal obligation is unmet in one way or another causing the individual to interpret a dysfunction in the self-sacrificial aspect of the job leading to increased burdensomeness, guilt, and self-discust (Ringer et al., 2021). This theory only provides rationale behind suicidal behavior but does not address factors that may prevent suicidal behavior or outcomes.

Interpersonal-Psychological Theory of Suicide

Similar to the eusociality theory of suicide, Streeb et al. (2019) discuss the Interpersonal-Psychological Theory of Suicide (IPTS). This theory poses that a person must believe in three constructs to engage in lethal suicidal behaviors which are thwarted belongingness, perceived burdensomeness, and acquired capability for suicidal behavior (Streeb et al. (2019).

It is only when one possess all three of these characteristics that a lethal suicide attempt is made. First responders have an elevated risk of attaining all three characteristics related to their work experience. Thwarted belongingness is the disconnection of belonging to one’s team for interpersonal reasons, work capability, and shared workload (Streeb et al., 2019). Perceived burdensomeness are represented in the same way as the eusociality theory, and acquired capability is increased due to close proximity of firearms, medications, chemicals, and other substances often used by first responders.

Other Causal Factors

Most other causal factors are related to the everyday responsibilities of first responders. One of the most prevalent causal factors is the increased exposure to traumatic events over time. This is true for firefighters, law enforcement officers, and emergency medical personnel. Truama exposure over time may also lead to post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) among first responders which positively correlates to suicidal ideation and attempts (Stanley et al., 2019).

Streeb et al., (2019) reported that 36.7% of firefighters had faced the threat of injury or their own death, 37.8% faced the threat of injury or death for a team member, and 61% responded to incidents that resulted in death of one or more persons. Aldrich and Cerel (2022) reported that law enforcement officers encounter around 2.17 suicide calls per year. This exposure to trauma and suicide itself is reported to increase rumination about suicide and suicidal ideation.

Alcohol use and sleep disturbances are other leading causal factors related to first responders’ suicidal behavior (Vigil et al., 2021). Alcohol use is often seen as a suppression system for dealing with everyday trauma associated with first responders’ work, and sleep disturbances occur as part of their regular work experience and expectation to respond to calls at any point during the day or night. All of these factors may compound on each other to further heighten the risk of suicide among the first responder population.

Treatments and Buffers

Mishara and Fortin (2022) found that simple educational and resource opportunities can significantly decrease suicide among first responders. They reported on a study where a half-day educational opportunity about suicide was offered to all law enforcement officers and a full-day workshop on suicide was required for anyone in a supervisory role in a town in Quebec, Canada. Implemented alongside this was a 24-hour phone line where psychiatrists could assist someone after a serious incident or help intervene during times of suicidal ideation. Mirshara and Fortin (2022) report that suicide among these law enforcement officers had reduced by over 50% in a 22 year follow-up study.

Having a supportive social network is also attributed with reduced suicide among first responders (Ringer et al., 2021; Streeb et al., 2019). This may be due to having a positive social outlet who acts as a third party when trying to analyze a situation providing a different perspective than someone who was at the scene as when debriefing with a team member. Positive social networks are seen as protective for other mental health problems as well such as PTSD, anxiety, and depression.

Stanley et al. (2019) report that interventions that include mindfulness as well as treatments used for PTSD would also be beneficial in reducing suicide among first responders. They cite Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), and mindfulness-based Cognitive Therapy as being beneficial for treating suicidal ideation and rumination among first responders (Stanley et al., 2019). They also report that DBT and prolonged exposure (PE) together proved more effective in reducing suicide attempts than DBT alone (Stanley et al., 2019).

Conclusion

Many causal factors and potential genetic predispositions create a perfect storm effect when reviewing suicide among first responders. Continued exposure to traumatic events leads to poor mental and physical health outcomes for this population which may exacerbate suicidal ideation. Some research shows, however, promising interventions for helping prevent suicide among first responder populations. There needs to be continued research in this area as suicide among first responders is still a very prominent health problem among this population.

References

Aldrich, R. S., & Cerel, J. (2022). Occupational Suicide Exposure and Impact on Mental Health: Examining Differences Across Helping Professions. Omega, 85(1), 23–37. https://doi.org/10.1177/0030222820933019

Mishara, B. L., & Fortin, L.-F. (2022). Long-term effects of a comprehensive police suicide prevention program: 22-year follow-up. Crisis: The Journal of Crisis Intervention and Suicide Prevention, 43(3), 183–189. https://doi.org/10.1027/0227-5910/a000774

Ringer, F. B., Rogers, M. L., Podlogar, M. C., Chu, C., Gai, A. R., & Joiner, T. (2021). To support and defend: A eusociality-based account of suicide in US military service members and first responders. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 28(4), 380–390. https://doi.org/10.1037/cps0000033

Stanley, I. H., Boffa, J. W., Tran, J. K., Schmidt, N. B., Joiner, T. E., & Vujanovic, A. A. (2019). Posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms and mindfulness facets in relation to suicide risk among firefighters. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 75(4), 696–709. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.22748

Streeb, N., Shoji, K., & Benight, C. C. (2019). The Capability for Suicide in Firefighters. Suicide & Life-Threatening Behavior, 49(4), 980–995. https://doi.org/10.1111/sltb.12500

Vigil, N. H., Beger, S., Gochenour, K. S., Frazier, W. H., Vadeboncoeur, T. F., & Bobrow, B. J. (2021). Suicide Among the Emergency Medical Systems Occupation in the United States. Western Journal of Emergency Medicine: Integrating Emergency Care with Population Health, 22(2), 326–332. https://doi.org/10.5811/westjem.2020.10.48742

Testimonials

“The totally online DBH program offered by Cummings Graduate Institute of Behavioral Health Studies is focused on the professional I have grown into: a synergistic disrupter for the healthcare industry, who is passionate about Wholistic Healthcare (e.g., health, behavioral health, and Social Determinants of Health and Mental Health), rendered skillfully through interprofessional teams. The program pillars of medical literacy, integrated behavioral health interventions, and entrepreneurship resonate loudly with me. The healthcare industry will continue to change, with doctoral level professionals needed to play a major role in any successful transformation. My goal is to further advance my knowledge-base, professional standing, and industry commitment to be part of these transformational efforts. In this way I can heed the Quadruple Aim: assuring quality-driven patient-centric care is rendered at the right time, through the right population-based treatment processes, at the right cost, and by empowered professionals embracing the work and committed to their charge.”
Ellen Fink-Samnick MSW, ACSW, LCSW, CCM, CRPDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - March 11, 2020

“In the time that I have been a student at CGI, I have learned that integrated healthcare is no longer the exception; providers want behavioral health clinicians on their team. My courses demonstrate that the services that a DBH can offer are valuable and the opportunities abound. I’m learning that as a DBH, I can work to create a new norm in healthcare, one that promotes holistic care provided by a collaborative team delivering diverse services. I now view behavioral healthcare as a crucial piece of the medical care puzzle, rather than a separate entity. I can see the gaps in care that a DBH can fill and why including a DBH in treatment is critical. I am beginning to see how I will play a role in disrupting healthcare to provide quality treatment while advocating for my patients. Although I may still have to explain my role at times, I am learning that once I do, others will seek out my services. I am gaining confidence in what I bring to the medical team and am continuously expanding my knowledge of what else I can do.”
Jennifer KellyDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - July 26, 2020

“As a Social Worker, I believe my main mission includes advocating for and empowering patients. The DBH degree will allow me to fully integrate the “medical side of the house” with the “behavioral health side”. My experience working side-by-side with medical providers (PCM’s, ED docs, Hospitalists, etc…) has shown that most of them do not understand behavioral health issues nor how medical symptoms or diagnoses can effect a patients’ mental health and vice-versa. Alternatively, I have worked with a multitude of behavioral health providers who have very limited knowledge of how medical issues might affect their clients. I have often wondered how many patients I have had who were diagnosed with depression or anxiety or other DSM-V diagnosis when in reality the origin was medical. Earning a DBH will allow me to push the envelope when it comes to consulting with medical providers and promote the inclusion of “behavioral healthcare” within “healthcare” as its ALL healthcare! As Mahatma Ghandi said “be the change you wish to see in the world”; earning a DBH will enhance my ability to “change the world” – even if it’s one medical provider or one patient at a time.”
Diane Scott, MSW, LCSWDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - August 7, 2020

“My friend and I were talking about the challenges and frustrations that we face daily in our careers with the clear divide between mental health and physical health and how we wished we had the knowledge and skills to shake up healthcare and bridge the gap. She brought up researching doctorate programs and how interested she was in the DBH. My reponse was, “What on earth is a DBH?” She laughed and said it was a newer doctorate degree in behavioral health, that focused directly on integrated care and doing exactly what we were dreaming of doing….shaking up healthcare and bridging the gap and treating the person as a whole. I had a hard time believing her. It sounded too good to be true. How was there a degree out there that fit my goals and aspirations to a T without me knowing about it? I had been looking periodically throughout my 20 year journey in behavioral health for a program that resonated with me. It was here all this time? How had I missed it? I immediately spent hours scouring the internet to find any crumb of information that I could about the Doctorate of Behavioral Health and the programs associated with it. Then I hit the jackpot. I found the Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies.”
Amy McConnell, LCSWDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - September 18, 2020

“During my tenure as a student at CGI, I wrote a book review that was published in the International Journal of Integrated Care. One of my papers became a newsletter article, a pitch for my population health class became a poster presented at a CFHA conference, a book chapter was developed based on a paper I wrote for my independent study, and I am submitting my CP project to a journal this weekend. So, everything that you write during the program is potentially publishable! You have the advantage of having faculty read and give you feedback on it before submitting it. Take risks! The worst that can happen if you submit a paper for publication is receiving a rejection letter. Well, if you don’t send it you’re already acting as if the paper had been rejected. 😉 Plus, if you receive a rejection letter, it usually comes with feedback, so you can improve your paper and send it again!”
Dr. Liliane de Aguiar-Rocha, DBH, BCBADBH Alumni, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - October 9, 2020

“There is a substantial need for integrating care between our physical, and mental health. The gap between these domains are more so overlooked among those with developmental delays and intellectual disabilities – the very population I serve as a Behavior Analyst. Filling these gaps entails work that demands for a DBH who is competent, empathetic, and altruistic.”
Pauline Pablo, BCBADBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - November 11, 2020

“My interest in a DBH degree grew out of frustration and hope. On one hand, I grew frustrated with the quality of care my clients with intellectual and developmental disabilities were receiving. As members of a marginalized population who lack the skills to advocate for themselves, the clients I serve receive subpar medical care, mental health care, and behavioral health care. Many healthcare providers are not trained to address the unique language and cognitive challenges present when serving a person with Autism and I/DD.

On the other hand, as I learned more about the DBH program, a potential solution came into view. I believe this program will allow me to acquire the knowledge and skills to become a better advocate for my clients, and new job opportunities will open up in positions in which I will be able to make a bigger impact on a system level, thus improving quality of life for many clients. A DBH degree will command interest and respect from other healthcare professionals who are evaluating their practices and noticing areas in which they are not being effective, namely the behavioral health side of the equation. As we are learning in our first classes about the Biodyne Model, the Integrated Care Model is not widely accepted or known in the healthcare field, despite its proven track record. I believe a DBH degree provides the necessary tool to change the landscape of healthcare provision by arming my passion for this topic with knowledge and concrete strategies.”
Valeria ParejoDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - January 15, 2021

“As a Doctorate of Behavioral Health (DBH) student my vision for healthcare is to disrupt the current model, close gaps to care and create healthcare improvements. In the evolving world of healthcare I believe behavioral healthcare providers (BCP) are essential to the development of integrative healthcare. Once I obtain a DBH degree, I know I will gain a leadership role and be able to add quality to the creation of integration efforts worldwide. I know I will graduate with the essential tools I need to stand at the forefront of integrated healthcare. I want to create healthcare improvements for marginalized populations that are typically underserved or forgotten. As an individual of two minority groups; woman and African American, I am very passionate about helping reduce cultural, ethnic, social economic and geographic disparities within healthcare systems.”
Ebony WatsonDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - March 30, 2021

“Since beginning my studies at CGI, I have been awakened to how much I truly did not know and understand despite my specialty training in Social Work and behavioral health needs. The classes at CGI allow me to explore topics that I may not have thought to investigate and encourage me to question and think outside the “normal” delivery of behavioral health services. Services that I previously thought were quality and designed to meet the needs of special populations, I now believe to be woefully inadequate to serve the needs of the patients. Patients cannot receive the best quality, efficient, and timely care they need and deserve within institutions that are not integrated. Institutions that continue to silo and do not encourage collaboration and integration are not focused on the needs of the patient.”
Amanda BarnardDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - March 30, 2021

“I believe, as a DBH, I will disrupt the current healthcare systemby promotingguaranteed health care for allasa right, not a privilege.I willadvocate fora national, rather than state, licensing of providers. This will allow clinicians (medical,behavioral health, etc…) to provide care across state lines using telemedicine.Finally, the skills I have learned at Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies allow me to identify healthcare delivery concerns, propose alternative interventions and cost–effective solutions and evaluate theirreturn on investment.”
Diane ScottDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - March 29, 2021

“Since entering CGI, I have more confidence in discussing the need for healthcare systems to have a population health approach to care, and to put in place “upstream” programming. I have always been proud of working in a hospital and delivering care, working as a multidisciplinary team member, and making a difference. I now realize I have been part of healthcare’s focus of “treating the sick” rather than being an influencer for preventative care.

Preventative care can be part of service delivery from a hospital system; we should not rely only on public health programs to tackle social determinants of health. COVID-19 is not only impacting mental health but also how we are delivering medical care. Could COVID-19 be an unintended force for healthcare policy change? Apostolopoulos et al. (2020) reports the complexity presented to the health care system by COVID-19 has created change that will continue in healthcare for years to come. The needed changes to delivery and access will require a policy shift in all levels of healthcare (Apostolopoulos et al., 2020).”
Billie RatliffDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - December 13, 2021

“The DBH is exactly the type of doctorate degree that I’ve been searching for. A doctorate that is clinical focused is where my interest lies. I am motivated to pursue this degree, and courses like Pathophysiology, Psychopharmacology, Neuropathophysiology, only add to that excitement. One must be motivated to complete any degree program. The Doctor of Behavioral Health fits that bill for me. In fact, I would say that I am beyond motivated.”
Arthur Williams IIIDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - July 8, 2022

“As a member of the AAPI community, I’m very familiar with the barriers to mental health services and the need to break through the glass wall of cultural stigma that prevents many from receiving potentially life–saving treatment. I was the only Asian American person in my master’s cohort, the only Asian American person in many of my clinical work settings, the only Asian American person to walk into many of the professional settings that I pushed myself to show up to. In my current practice, I’m constantly reminded by my patients of how difficult it is to find an Asian American mental health provider, though this reminder constantly informs me that more needs to be done for my community. Day after day, I read stories of Asian American people who die by suicide as a consequence of our culture’s avoidance of mental health topics. As a DBH, my biggest goal is to use my expertise in whole–person care to amplify the conversation around mental health and help my community understand that mental healthcare is not a privilege that we are not entitled to, it is a crucial part of our healthcare that will manifest differently in us than what many Western psychology or psychiatry textbooks will describe, and that our unique experience of mental health issues are valid, important, and is time to be part of the larger conversation.”
Willam ChumDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - September 16, 2022

“Pursuing a doctorate in behavioral health is essential in helping to transform my thinking as a healthcare provider; moving from a more traditional mindset, embracing change and a “different world view” of tools for successful client outcomes. This type of advanced study will equip me with the clinical and leadership skills to be a leader on the cutting edge of behavioral health. This type of training would make me an asset to the healthcare workplace; specifically to function effectively as a change agent for the successful outcomes of the workplace and its clients.”
Judith AllenDBH Candidate, Cummings Graduate Institute for Behavioral Health Studies - September 23, 2022 Previous Slide